PVC Decking vs Hardwood: What Homeowners Learn After 5 Years

When selecting decking materials, homeowners often opt for PVC decking under the impression that it promises low maintenance and longevity. However, after five years, many discover drawbacks such as heat retention, a plastic feel, fading, and limited repairability. In contrast, hardwood decking offers an authentic appearance and a different set of maintenance realities. This post will explore the implications of these two materials, helping you make a more informed decision for your decking project.

Quick Summary

• Heat Retention: PVC can become excessively hot in sunlight, affecting outdoor comfort.
• Aesthetic Appeal: Hardwood offers a natural look that many homeowners prefer.
• Repairability: Damaged hardwood can often be sanded or refinished, while PVC requires replacement.
• Long-Term Costs: Initial saving on PVC may lead to higher costs in repairs or replacement.
• Environmental Considerations: Hardwood is a renewable resource, whereas PVC is a synthetic product.

What is PVC Decking and Hardwood Decking?

PVC decking is made from polyvinyl chloride, a type of plastic engineered for durability and resistance to moisture. While it offers appealing colors and textures, it is often criticized for its faux appearance and thermal properties.
Hardwood decking, such as Ipe, Cumaru, or Tigerwood, is derived from premium exotic woods native to tropical regions. It is known for its rich colors, natural grain patterns, and incredible durability, often lasting decades with proper care.

Best Use Cases

• PVC Decking: Ideal for homeowners seeking quick installation and those in environments with high humidity, where wood might rot. It works well in residential pool areas for its superior moisture resistance.
• Hardwood Decking: Best suited for aesthetic-conscious homeowners and those in moderate climates who appreciate the beauty of natural wood and are willing to invest time in maintenance for longevity.

Pros of PVC Decking

• Low Maintenance: Requires less regular maintenance, such as sealing or staining.
• Moisture Resistant: Naturally resistant to rot and mold, making it suitable for wet locations.
• Variety of Colors: Comes in a range of colors and textures, allowing customization.
• Ease of Installation: Can often be installed quickly due to its lightweight nature.

Cons and Limitations of PVC Decking

• Heat Retention: Can become extremely hot under sunlight, making it uncomfortable for bare feet.
• Plastic Feel: Often criticized for feeling unnaturally plastic-like, detracting from its aesthetic value.
• Fading: Colors can fade over time due to UV exposure, diminishing visual appeal.
• Limited Repairability: If damaged, the entire plank may need to be replaced instead of repaired.

Pros of Hardwood Decking

• Natural Beauty: Offers unique grain patterns and colors that enhance visual aesthetics.
• Durability: Species like Ipe can withstand heavy foot traffic, pests, and harsher weather conditions.
• Repairability: Can be sanded down and refinished to remove scratches, dings, or stains.
• Thermal Comfort: Generally cooler to the touch compared to PVC, making it more comfortable in hot weather.

Cons and Limitations of Hardwood Decking

• Higher Initial Cost: Tends to be more expensive upfront than PVC alternatives.
• Maintenance Needs: Requires periodic sealing or oiling to maintain appearance and prevent weathering.
• Vulnerability to Rot: If improperly maintained or installed, hardwood can rot or attract insects.

Installation Considerations

When installing decking, both materials have specific requirements:

• PVC Decking: Can be installed using either square edge boards for face-screwed applications or grooved boards for hidden fasteners. Ensure proper spacing to allow for expansion and contraction.
• Hardwood Decking: For best results, use square edge boards for a secure face-screw installation or grooved boards with hidden fasteners. Proper joist spacing is essential to prevent warping.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

1. Ignoring Heat Retention: Test the materials on a hot day to understand how hot they can get before purchasing.
2. Installation Errors: Ensure correct spacing between boards to allow for expansion in both materials.
3. Overlooking Maintenance: For hardwood, set a schedule for cleaning and treating to maintain longevity; PVC may require fewer interventions, but still maintain routine cleaning to avoid stains.

Cost Considerations

• PVC Decking: Initial investment can be lower, often around $3-$8 per square foot. Consider potential replacement costs in the future.
• Hardwood Decking: The initial cost can range from $7-$15 per square foot, but this competes with prolonged life and the ability to refurbish.

Maintenance and Longevity

While PVC decking requires minimal upkeep, it may not age gracefully, leading to a need for replacements. Hardwood decking, on the other hand, typically lasts over 25 years with proper maintenance, allowing for refinishing every few years to keep it looking new.

Real-World Recommendations

• What WE Would Do: Given our expertise, we recommend hardwood if aesthetics and longevity are your primary concerns, especially for moderate climates. The investment in quality hardwood like Ipe or Cumaru is worthwhile for both beauty and durability in the long run.
• Check out our comparisons to see how different options stack up: Ipe vs Azek, Ipe vs TimberTech, or Ipe vs Composite.

FAQ Section

1. What are the advantages of PVC decking over hardwood?

PVC decking is generally cheaper to install and requires less maintenance compared to hardwood.

2. How does hardwood decking hold up in various climates?

Quality hardwood decking like Ipe is incredibly durable and can withstand various climatic conditions, provided it's maintained properly.

3. Can PVC decking fade overtime?

Yes, exposure to UV light can cause PVC decking colors to fade, diminishing its aesthetic appeal.

4. Is it possible to repair damaged hardwood decking?

Yes, hardwood decking can be sanded and refinished, allowing for repairs that can maintain its beauty and extend its life.